Investors who are currently in the market may be sitting on some handsome profits, especially if they were astute enough to have started buying late last year.
The S&P/ASX 200 is approaching the key 4350 resistance level. This level has been a barrier of resistance since last July and investors should be looking to protect their profits. Profit protection can be obtained by outright selling the position, or by buying a protective put, as discussed last year in the article Options Trading (Part 1): The Protective Put.
However there can be reasons why a long term investor may not want to cash out at this time, such as capital gains tax or perhaps an upcoming dividend. A cheaper alternative to buying a Protective Put would be to enter into a Bear Put Spread, which limits the cost of the protection, but also limits the degree of protection.
Cheaper Protection Using Bear Put Spreads
A Bear Put Spread is an options strategy that can be used to buy put options at a discount and can be particularly useful when you have an existing stock position that you want to protect. It is a debit spread that can be an effective way of hedging an underlying share position, as it allows investors to purchase put options at a relatively cheaper cost than an outright put purchase.
The Bear Put Spread is an option strategy that makes its maximum profit when the underlying stock declines to the short strike and has its maximum risk if the stock rises in price to the long strike. The strategy is to be implemented using puts, where an option with a higher striking price is purchased and one with a lower striking price is sold simultaneously, both options generally having the same expiration date.
The Bear Put Spread option strategy is established by selling to open an Out of the Money (OTM) put option, which effectively reduces the cost of the In the Money (ITM) or At The Money (ATM) Put options. This reduces the upfront payment and therefore the risk of the position, making it an ideal option trading strategy for investors who want protection from falls in a down market, while holding on to their existing position (hedging).
Standalone, the Bear Put Spread is a bearish option strategy that profits when the underlying stock price falls. The Bear Put Spread involves simultaneously buying to open and selling to open options of the same expiration month, making it a Vertical Spread and because you need to pay money to put on this position, resulting in a net debit, this is also known as a Debit Spread.
A debit spread profits from a move in the share price through the purchase of an option near at-the-money (ATM) (or ITM), whilst reducing the cost of the trade by selling an option further out of the money (OTM). The advantage of the debit spread is that the cost of purchasing the option is lowered, while the downside to this strategy is that the profit is capped by the sold options, and this is why the investors must choose their option strikes carefully, so as to attain a good risk reward trade.
The debit spreads are directional trades as they benefit with an increase in volatility, and as such, a directional move in the share price. Note that if the trader expects a short sharp move in the near-term, then they would be better off simply buying a protective put.
Recent Trade – Toll Holdings
A recent trade that our clients took was to buy Toll Holdings around $4.50 in late January. The stock surged 17% in the subsequent couple of weeks. Clients were then faced with the dilemma of taking profits now or holding on for the dividend in early March.
We suggested that they could hedge their position using a bear put strategy – by buying a ATM Put & Selling an OTM Put.
In this trade with TOL trading at $5.20, the bear put strategy was established by Buying to Open TOLL 525 MAR12 Put for 23.5c and Selling to Open TOLL 476 MAR12 Put 7c, for a total outlay of 17.5c (ie. Net debit= 23.5c – 7c).
Note if you were more pessimistic and expected TOL to fall to $4.50 by expiration, you would have sold the 450 MAR12 Puts.
Risks and Profit Potential
The Bear Put Spread profits when the stock price falls towards the short strike, as the long put option will rise in price along with the underlying stock price, while the short put options continue to decay in premium. The maximum profit potential of a bear put spread is when the price of the underlying stock drops down to the strike price of the out of the money (OTM) short options, as beyond that price any gain in the long put options is matched exactly by a loss in the short put options.
Profit Calculation of the TOL Bear Put Spread:
Maximum Return = (Difference in strikes – Net Debit) ÷ Net Debit
Following up from the recent trade example:
Buy to open 10 TOL MAR12 525 Put for 23.5c per contract and sell to open 10 TOL MAR12 476 Put for 7c per contract.
Maximum Return = (525 – 476 – (23.5 – 7)) ÷ (23.5 – 7) = 31.5 ÷ 17.5 = 180%
Maximum Risk = Net Debit = 23.5c – 7c = 17.5, if TOL share price is > $5.25
Break Even = Higher Strike – Net Debit = 525 – 17.5 = $5.075
In summary the Bear Put Strategy offers a maximum risk limited to the Net Debit Paid, while the maximum loss is limited and the maximum upside profit is also limited. These risk/rewards are shown in the Payoff diagram.
Note this strategy can be used in order to hedge an underlying Toll Holdings stock position, while the investor is still eligible for the dividend payment in early March.
The Trade
Options can be used in order to reduce/hedge your risk, while still participating in potential profits from a significant move by the underlying stock. We have explained the Bear Put Spread strategy which can be used to allow you to protect an existing share position, while maintaining the benefits of ownership of the underlying stock.
In future articles we will talk about the High Yield Covered Call strategy and the Covered Call Stock Reversal strategy which is particularly relevant to this market.
Utilise the features in the Market Analyser software to plan your options trades for a particular options strategy using your specific trade selection criteria. You will save time and potentially reduce your trading risk.
By Michael Hevern
Trading Desk
** Please note your may need to refer to a tax profession regarding eligibility of franking credits.
See Also:
Options Trading for All Types of Market Environments (Part 1): The Protective Put
Options Trading for All Types of Market Environments (Part 2): The Covered Call
Options Trading for All Types of Market Environments (Part 3): The Covered Call Collar
Options Trading for All Types of Market Environments (Part 4): The Stock Repair Strategy
Options Trading for All Types of Market Environments (Part 5): Limited Risk Short Selling Strategy
Options Trading for All Types of Market Environments (Part 7): Dividend Capture Covered Call Collar
For Buy and Sell recommendations on ASX listed companies register for a FREE trial of MDS Financial Research.
MDS Financial Advisory Service offers general advice on trading options to generate consistent steady income on your investment portfolio. For further information please call 1300 610 024.

























